go to top

Over the Horizon: The Art of the Reasonable in North Korea

Wednesday, Dec. 21, 2011

Kim Jong Il is dead, and the world is wondering what to do about it. The task of leading North Korea has fallen to an inexperienced 27-year-old without a major constituency, even as the threat of regime collapse worries both friends and enemies of the largely isolated nation. What should Washington, Beijing, Seoul and Tokyo do in order to avoid a crisis? Some observers are arguing that this represents an opportunity for the United States to push hard against the DPRK, hopefully causing it to topple. This would be a mistake; the DPRK is likely not only to survive such pressure, but to respond by lashing out in dangerous and unpredictable ways. A much better approach would be to reach out to North Korean factions potentially interested in reintegrating the DPRK into the international community, in the hopes of tipping the balance of power within the regime.

Kim Jong Il’s legacy is clear. He utterly failed to adjust to the post-Cold War reality, in which North Korea could no longer depend on the good graces of the Soviet Union and in which even the support of the People’s Republic of China could be tenuous. He devoted enormous resources to a nuclear weapons program that gave the DPRK no significant strategic advantage and further contributed to its international isolation. Kim also failed to open the North Korean economy in any meaningful way, leading to a collapse in North Korean living standards. Finally, the DPRK’s human rights record under Kim’s rule has been unspeakably awful. In the end, Kim’s signal achievement was the ability to survive long enough to die in power, without even having assured the succession of his son, Kim Jong Un. ...

To read more,

enter your email address then choose one of the three options below.

Subscribe to World Politics Review and you'll receive instant access to 10,000+ articles in the World Politics Review Library, along with new comprehensive analysis every weekday . . . written by leading topic experts.