On Wednesday, Gen. Abdel-Fattah El-Sisi, Egypt's military chief of staff, announced that the country's elected president, Mohammed Morsi, had been removed from office. Egypt's constitution will be suspended; Adly Mansour, the chief judge of the Constitutional Court, will temporarily assume the presidency and oversee a transitional government until new elections can be held at a date yet to be determined. The events of the "second Egyptian revolution" have effectively terminated the experiment as to whether the Muslim Brotherhood, having won parliamentary and presidential elections last year, would be able to construct a democratic regime. They now present the Obama administration with an unpleasant choice: to support an elected but illiberal leader or to accept a military coup d'etat in order to preserve the possibility of a secular, liberal Egypt.
History is no guide for finding a consistent answer to the dilemma that events in Egypt present. In Haiti, for instance, the United States opposed the 1991 ouster of Jean-Bertrand Aristide by the military due to his penchant for using authoritarian means for pushing reform—including efforts to bring the armed forces under firm civilian control—and helped restore him to his position in 1994. By contrast, in 2004, when Aristide was again pushed from office, the U.S. position, expressed by then-Secretary of State Colin Powell, was that Aristide "was democratically elected, but he did not democratically govern, or govern well." When it comes to Egypt and Morsi’s fate, there are signs that the Obama administration will lean toward the latter approach in crafting its response. ...
To read the rest, sign up to try World Politics Review
- TWO WEEKS FREE.
- Cancel any time.
- After two weeks, just $18 monthly or $118/year.
Request a free trial for your office or school. Everyone at a given site can get access through our institutional subscriptions.
- Without Chad, Central African Republic Peace Talks Unlikely to Succeed
- As Talks Stall, South Sudan Conflict Grinds to Stalemate
- The Realist Prism: U.S. Watches From Sidelines as Global Leaders Gather in Brazil
- Regional Security Role Shields Mauritania’s Aziz From Pressure to Reform
- Climate Change Driving Farmer-Herder Conflict in Niger River Basin