The U.N. General Assembly meets today to elect five new nonpermanent members of the Security Council, ushering in the end of a two-year period in which three major powers held temporary seats. But although Germany, India and South Africa played prominent roles in debates over Libya and Syria, the chances of fundamental changes to the council’s structures seem less likely today than they did two years ago.

At the Security Council, Compromise and Reforms in Short Supply

By , , Briefing

The United Nations General Assembly meets today to elect five new nonpermanent members of the Security Council. Although the winners will not begin their terms until January, the U.N. is approaching the end of two turbulent years in which three major powers -- Germany, India and South Africa -- have held temporary seats in the council, playing prominent roles in its debates over Libya and Syria.  All three aspire to permanent seats in the forum, but have no choice but to head for the exit. (Colombia and Portugal are also off.) 

When the trio of powers won seats on the council two years ago, Bruce D. Jones and I warned in these pages that there was no guarantee that they would cooperate easily with the council’s five permanent members: the U.S, China, France, Russia and the U.K., collectively known as the P5. But we also argued that their presence could restore real credibility to the council, which has repeatedly been criticized for failing to adapt to changing global power dynamics. At the time, it seemed that the U.N. agenda would be dominated by African issues, such as South Sudan’s transition to independence and elections in Liberia and the Democratic Republic of the Congo. There was no reason to think that such matters would create major rifts in New York. ...

To read the rest, sign up to try World Politics Review

Free Trial

Sign up for two weeks of free access with your credit card. Cancel any time during the free trial and you will be charged nothing.



Request a free trial for your office or school. Everyone at a given site can get access through our institutional subscriptions.

request trial


Already a member? Click the button below to login.