go to top
Afghan National Army soldiers open fire into mountains during an ongoing war in the Dangam district of Kunar province, Afghanistan, Dec. 28, 2014 (AP photo by Rahim Faiez).

What Are the Real Lessons of the Afghanistan War?

Friday, Jan. 2, 2015

A few days ago, U.S. Army General John Campbell announced the formal end of the U.S. combat mission in Afghanistan. “The longest war in American history is coming to a responsible conclusion,” U.S. President Barack Obama then added. Whether accurate or not, the declaration of victory launched a scramble among national security experts to identify the strategic lessons of Afghanistan. The stakes of this debate are high. Because the lessons of Afghanistan will shape American security policy for decades, it is vital to get them right.

The process of identifying strategic lessons is always rife with tempting missteps. For Afghanistan, one of these might be called the “never again” position. Proponents of this position are found on both the political left and right, but all insist that Afghanistan shows that the United States simply cannot succeed at counterinsurgency and should avoid it in the future. Yet while it is true that “None of the claimed long term objectives for the war, either from the Bush or Obama administrations, have been achieved,” as Dan Murphy wrote in the Christian Science Monitor,it would be a mistake to draw universal conclusions from Afghanistan. The lack of success there does not prove that counterinsurgency in general is impossible, but that the U.S. needs to better recognize when it can and cannot work, and know when to resist deep involvement. ...

To read more,

enter your email address then choose one of the three options below.

Subscribe to World Politics Review and you'll receive instant access to 10,000+ articles in the World Politics Review Library, along with new comprehensive analysis every weekday . . . written by leading topic experts.