As Hillary Clinton prepares to step down as secretary of state, the consensus is that she helped to restore America's image in the world but was not a transformational figure for U.S. diplomacy. Someone else at Foggy Bottom, it has been implied, might have accomplished more. In reality, for foreign governments seeking to deal with Washington, the secretary of state is now just one of several options.

The Realist Prism: Amid Crowded Field in D.C., Kerry Should Keep Aims Modest

By , , Column

As Hillary Clinton prepares to step down as secretary of state, the general consensus among the punditocracy is that she was successful in helping to restore America's image in the world: A "rockstar diplomat," Clinton was willing to put in the frequent flyer miles to help repair or rebuild frayed ties between Washington and many other countries. However, she is not viewed as a transformational figure for U.S. diplomacy, nor can she point to a particularly dramatic event, such as a comprehensive Middle East peace settlement, as a result of her tenure in office. Some of the comments in this vein imply that had someone else occupied the executive suite at Foggy Bottom, things might have turned out differently.

Of course, the effectiveness of any secretary of state is enhanced if he or she has a close personal relationship with the president and is perceived by foreign leaders to be speaking for the White House. In this regard, Condoleezza Rice, who many saw as George W. Bush's personal emissary, may have had an advantage over Clinton. It also helps if the secretary of state emerges as the primus inter pares of the foreign policymaking process. Henry Kissinger, for instance, chose not to relinquish the post of national security adviser when he became Richard Nixon’s secretary of state precisely to hold onto that role. ...

To read the rest, sign up to try World Politics Review

Individual
Free Trial

  • TWO WEEKS FREE.
  • Cancel any time.
  • After two weeks, just $18 monthly or $118/year.
subscribe

Institutional
Subscriptions

Request a free trial for your office or school. Everyone at a given site can get access through our institutional subscriptions.

request trial

Login

Already a member? Click the button below to login.

login